| Platinum | Tony's Taco Shop |
| Gold | La Margarita Company Restaurant & Grill |
| Silver | La Hacienda Real |
| Bronze | Los Dos Hermanos |
| Top Pick | Azuls Taco House |
| Top Pick | Don Froylan Creamery |
| Top Pick | Don Juan's Tacos & More |
| Top Pick | Habaneros |
| Top Pick | Las Islas Marias |
| Top Pick | Los Arcos |