| Platinum | Nancy Jo's Burgers & Fries |
| Gold | Cafe 22 West |
| Silver | Miller's BBQ & Cafe |
| Bronze | The Ritz |
| Top Pick | ACME Cafe |
| Top Pick | Black Sheep Cafe & Catering |
| Top Pick | Gerry Frank's Konditorei |
| Top Pick | Josey's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Toast & Jam |
| Top Pick | Venti's Cafe & Tap House |